Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Spreading the gratitude around

A cousin writes that she is "sending thanks out to everyone who has served our country or has supported family members in the military. They rarely get the credit and recognition they deserve."

My response: "I'd like to see them get more benefits. I think twice yearly national holidays with full media coverage, lots of speeches, assemblies in every school, and special attention at every major sporting event and performance is enough credit and recognition. No other group gets so much."

Beyond that, I think these twice yearly, lip-service-only holidays contribute to a culture of war by honoring only service in the cause of war. Here is my post from last year where I go into more detail about my feelings about this.

I refuse to celebrate [veterans of WWII] as the greatest generation because in doing so we are celebrating courage and sacrifice in the cause of war. And we are miseducating the young to believe that military heroism is the noblest form of heroism, when it should be remembered only as the tragic accompaniment of horrendous policies driven by power and profit.
~ Howard Zinn


Here is the list of some of the people I am honoring today for their service in the cause of equality and peace:

9 comments:

Stephanie said...

I am in total agreement with you and with Mr. Zinn.
From birth, our kids--especially the boys--are assured that military heroics are to be respected, even sought. Well, I say teach peace, vigorously!

Idzie said...

LOVE the Howard Zinn quote. That's exactly how I feel about things, but I hadn't been able to put into words.

Holly Simpson said...

I soooo agree with you, Ronnie!!

Michael said...

Howard Zinn...another one of my heroes!

woodchuck said...

Oh, this is awesome! I had the same feeling, but always felt kinda guilty about it. I guess I know why now. What a wonderful point you make here! Thank you!

Scott said...

Ronnie - I hope that you have thanked all of those INDIVIDUALS, individually.

Ronnie said...

Yep, just did, Scott. But the individuals listed here are merely examples to show the groups of largely unrecognized people that I wish our country honored as much as we honor our veterans.

Scott said...

If we agreed on everything it wouldn't be any fun.

Ronnie said...

I suppose, but that you disagree with me makes me worry that I haven't made my point. One more try:

My only objection to Veterans Day is the lack of balance. As a nation, we don't recognize peaceful people, too. An additional national holiday would help!

Given the imbalance, I think our two holidays for recognizing vets are enough. They send a loud message of thanks, since vets are the only groups we so honor.

Finally, I very much wish our veterans received tangible benefits instead of two-days-a-year empty words.

And I didn't talk about this before, but I'll add that the hypocrisy of vote-seeking politicians who will go on and on about supporting our troops but then will repeatedly vote against actual support *really* bothers me. And since so many such pols take Vets Day as a chance to grandstand, the whole holiday is tainted, for me, by their hypocrisy.